The K-pop industry, famous for producing global superstars like BTS, SEVENTEEN, and BlackPink, is facing a challenging time.

While these artists continue to gain popularity worldwide, their success has not been mirrored at home.

  • Domestic sales are dropping
  • new groups aren’t gaining the same level of attention
  • And major K-pop companies are seeing their stock prices fall.

Read: Some of K-Pop’s Toughest Choreography: From “MAESTRO” to “Run BTS” – from soompi

This post explores the reasons behind this crisis and what it means for the future of K-pop.

A Shift in the K-pop Landscape

South Korea’s K-pop industry, a cornerstone of the broader “hallyu” or “Korean Wave” phenomenon, is facing a notable crisis. Despite the global success of mega-stars like BTS, BlackPink, and Psy, domestic sales are in decline, and new bands are struggling to match the fervor of their predecessors. This domestic slump has been accompanied by a significant drop in stock prices for major K-pop agencies, indicating investor concerns about the industry’s future.

The Hidden Story Behind RIIZE’s Missing Member: Seunghan’s Controversy and Its Impact
source: Riize official instagram page

The Global Success Conundrum

The international triumphs of K-pop idols have, paradoxically, contributed to the challenges at home. As groups like BTS and BlackPink focus on broadening their appeal to global audiences—releasing music in multiple languages and appearing on international charts and talk shows—they risk alienating the South Korean fans who were instrumental in their initial rise to fame.

Domestic Versus International Popularity

Park Saing-in, an economist at Seoul National University, suggests that while K-pop’s global popularity remains strong, the domestic market’s struggles are evident. New acts such as Baby Monster, ITZY, and NMIXX have failed to make a significant impact on South Korea’s Melon Top 100, and established groups like Le Sserafim are experiencing steep declines in album sales.

Read: Meet Forbes Korea’s Most Influential Celebrities of 2024

Stock Market Woes

The uncertainty surrounding the domestic market has significantly impacted the stock prices of the four largest K-pop management agencies. YG Entertainment, HYBE, SM Entertainment, and JYP Entertainment have all seen substantial drops in their share values since the beginning of the year. This financial decline reflects investor anxiety over the industry’s ability to produce the next generation of superstar groups.

Seventeen's Historic Glastonbury Debut: A K-pop Milestone

Scandal and Disruption

Compounding the market challenges are disruptions caused by scandals and mandatory national service. BTS, for example, is on hiatus due to members fulfilling their national service obligations. Meanwhile, scandals, such as the backlash against Aespa’s Karina for her relationship with actor Lee Jae-wook, highlight the fragile relationship between idols and their fans. These scandals can lead to intense fan reactions and further erode the domestic fanbase.

The Post-Pandemic Shift

David Tizzard, an assistant professor at Seoul Women’s University, notes that much of hallyu culture peaked during the COVID-19 pandemic when people sought comfort in South Korean music and dramas. However, as the pandemic has receded, some fans have moved on, seeking new forms of entertainment. Tizzard believes that while the breadth of hallyu culture may have diminished, the depth of engagement among remaining fans remains strong.

Read: SEVENTEEN to be Appointed UNESCO’s First-Ever Goodwill Ambassador for Youth

Uncertain Future

The future of K-pop, while currently stable, is far from assured. Park Saing-in warns that the industry must continuously evolve to maintain its momentum. The decline in popularity of South Korean television dramas serves as a cautionary tale for K-pop, suggesting that without innovation and adaptation, the music industry could face similar challenges.

Blackpink, from YG entertainment, Korea's power celebrity 2024, Forbes
source: official Blackpink on Instagram

In conclusion, while K-pop’s global appeal remains undeniable, the industry faces significant hurdles in maintaining its domestic market. The balance between international success and local fan loyalty, coupled with the need to manage scandals and disruptions, will determine whether K-pop can sustain its current structure or if it will undergo a profound transformation.

Source: DW